Monday, August 23, 2010

Gabriel's journal #1: Crime and Punishment

When first looking at the title of this book, I thought that the story would be about a person in a pitiful situation struggling to get by, having to take bold action in order to come out of their turmoil and suffer the consequences, “crime” followed by “punishment”. I find that my first prediction of the book is fairly accurate. It opens with a college student, behind several months in rent and in poor favor with his land lady. Raskolnikov, seemingly fueled by his unfortunate financial situation to commit an “awful act” does in fact have a “just” conscience. Raskolnikov shows an admirable amount of charity and concern for others despite his misfortune.
Raskolnikov’s seems to reveal more about his identity, despite his efforts to stay elusive. Raskolnikov charitable actions towards Marmeladov the government official and concern for the young drunk woman reflect some sanity in Raskolnikov. Though his new habit of drinking seems to calm his nerves, I predict it will be what drives him to commit the “awful act”, especially since his sober conscience worries him enough to renounce his plans.

1 comment:

  1. When I first glanced at the book, I thought the same thing! Turns out we're both correct! I agree that though Raskolnikov did commit a horrible crime, he still exudes a sense of humanity uncommon to most murderers. His surroundings also do seem to negatively influence his behavior.

    ReplyDelete